Pogledaj jedan post
Old 03.11.2003., 01:17   #83
Quote:
novamama kaže:
Jos jedna kontradikcija u Kuranu, ovog puta na racun Zidova:

Sura 9.30:

Jevreji govore: "Uzejr je - Allahov sin", a kršćani kažu: "Mesih je - Allahov sin."* To su riječi njihove, iz usta njihovih, oponašaju riječi nevjernika prijašnjih - ubio ih Allah! Kuda se odmeću?


Nikad i nigdje Zidovi nisu rekli niti stoji u SZ napisano, da je Uzejr Allahov sin, odnosno Jahvin sin. Dakle, izmisljotina ala Kuran.
Jevreji(jevrejska sekta koja je dosla Poslaniku da vodi sa njim 'dijalog') iz Jemena su vjerovali da je Ezra(Uzeir) sin Boziji (a da to nije Isa-Mesih).
Enciklopedia Judaica, Tom. 6


Ezra in Islam. Muhammed claims (Sura 9:30) that in the opinion of the Jews, Uzayr (Ezra) is the son of God. These words are enigma because no such opinion is to be found among the Jews, even though Ezra was singled out for special appreciation (see Sanh. 21b; Yev. 86b). The Muslim traditionalists attempt to explain the words of Muhammed with a Muslim legend, whose origin appears to stem from IV Ezra 14:18-19. The people of Israel sinned, they were punished by God, the Holy Ark was removed, and the Torah was forgotten. I was due, however, to Ezra's merit that his heart was filled with the Torah of God, which he taught to people of Israel. When the Holy Ark was returned to them and they compared that which Ezra taught them with the text of the Sefer Torah in the Holy Ark, the words they found were identical. They deduced from this that Ezra was the son of Allah. Tabari cites another version of this legend: the Jewish scholars themselfes did the Ark, after they were beaten by the Amalekites. H.Z. Hirschberg proposed another assumption, based on words of Ibn Hazm (I,99), namely, that the "righteous" who live in Yemen believe that Uzayr was indeed the son of Allah. According to other Muslim sources, there were some Yemenite Jews who had converted to Islam who believed that Ezra was the messiah. For Muhammed, Ezra, the apostle of the messiah, can be seen in the same light as the Christian saw Jesus, the messiah, the son of Allah. An allusion to the figure of Erza as the apostle of the messiah is found in a tale which is widespread among the Jews of Yemen, according to which Ezra requested that they emigrate to Erez Israel, and because they did not, he cursed them. Yemenite Jews have therefore refrained from naming their children Ezra.
Adura is offline  
Odgovori s citatom